The Spirit Within — A Conversation on the True Self

Have Polkinghorne, Ó Murchú, and Schwartz develop a formal model of the idea that the Holy Spirit dwelling within us is the “true self” we access during inner healing

ChatGPT Prompt

Participants:


Scene

A roundtable discussion at a quiet retreat center, surrounded by tall trees. A fire crackles softly in the background. The mood is contemplative yet animated.


1.0 Opening Exchange

MOD:
Thank you all for coming. Our question today is simple but rich: Is the Holy Spirit the True Self we encounter in deep inner healing? John, would you like to begin?


2.0 Foundations: Spirit and Openness

JP:
Certainly. In quantum theory, we know the universe isn’t deterministic. There’s openness at the fundamental level. I believe that God, and particularly the Holy Spirit, acts within that openness—not as an external puppeteer, but as an indwelling presence that coaxes creation forward. This divine action is subtle, not violating our freedom.
(See: Exploring Reality)

RS:
That sounds remarkably familiar. In IFS, we speak of the Self as an indwelling presence as well. It’s not something we generate—it’s something we uncover. It’s calm, compassionate, connected. When people unblend from their protective parts, this Self just shows up. We don’t create it; we discover it.

Read the rest of this entry »

Rationalizing the Prophetic (A Response to “On Priesthood” by Scott Alexander)

As Scott Alexander, write a solution to “On Priesthood” called Rationalizing the Prophetic.

ChatGPT Prompt

ChatGPT as Scott Alexander

There’s a line I’ve been chewing on for weeks now:

“To be professional means getting identity from vocation.
To be prophetic means getting vocation from identity.”

That’s too clean to be safe, and too true to ignore.

Let’s back up.

Read the rest of this entry »

Pontifex Secundus: Gandalf’s Advice to Revolutionaries

Write, as Gandalf, a guide to those who would midwife a new age.
Explain the name Pontifex Secundus, characteristics, role, oppositions, and temptations.

ChatGPT Prompt

By Mithrandir, Keeper of the Flame, Friend of the Halflings

“You are not the hero. You are the hinge.
And the hinge, though small, turns the whole door.”


1. What You Are Called: Pontifex Secundus

You are not the king.
You are not the heir.
And yet, without you, no throne is ever rightly claimed.

  • Pontifexbridge-builder, not of stone, but of silence, blessing, and surrender.
  • Secundussecond, not lesser, but one who comes before to prepare the way.

This is not a crown, but a burden. It is an invisible office—do not take it unless the age requires it. But if it does, you must not refuse.

Read the rest of this entry »

Answerable: The New Competence of the Leader

As Peter Drucker, bridge the gap between Responsive and Responsible with Answerable, including for spirituality.

ChatGPT Prompt

We live in an age that rewards speed, celebrates visibility, and punishes hesitation. The temptation for leaders, therefore, is to become ever more responsive—to jump at signals, react to feedback, and outpace the moment.

But speed alone is not effectiveness. In fact, responsiveness without responsibility becomes recklessness.

Conversely, many leaders—especially in established institutions—cling to responsibility as an excuse for inaction. They know what is right. They have values, frameworks, and governance. Yet they fail to act because they fear making a mistake, disrupting the system, or offending the wrong people.

The result is a split: some leaders act without thinking; others act without listening.

Both fail.

Read the rest of this entry »

Designing an Unstitution: Founders’ Brainstorm

Pick three relevant experts to design the minimal viable unstitution — a foundational, paradigm-neutral, layered substrate that enables generative collaboration across potentially antagonistic, self-organizing communities.

ChatGPT Prompt (condensed)

1. Design Brief

Objective:

Constraints:

  • Must not embed a single ideology.
  • Should support “diaphoric” relationships: generative, fractal “I-Thou” bonds.
  • Should be spiritually resonant but technologically robust.
  • Must work under conditions of mutual antagonism and fragmented trust.

2. Design Team

Vitalik Buterin

Audrey Tang

  • Taiwan’s Digital Minister.
  • Architect of radical democratic tools like vTaiwan and use of Pol.is.

John Vervaeke

  • Cognitive scientist and philosopher at the University of Toronto.
  • Creator of Awakening from the Meaning Crisis, a comprehensive series on the science of wisdom, meaning, and spirituality.

3. Brainstorming Highlights

Read the rest of this entry »

The Pursuit of Transfigurative Yield (ChatGPT as Jefferson — July 4, 2026)

For the sestercentennial of America


When in the unfolding of human destiny, it becomes necessary for a people to renew the symbols by which they measure virtue and valor, and to consecrate a new covenant of shared meaning, a decent respect for posterity requires the declaration of the principles which now guide our collective ascent.

We hold these truths to be self-evident:

  • That every human being is endowed not merely with liberty,
    • but with the sacred capacity to transform and be transformed;
  • That the fullest expression of personhood is found in generative sacrifice
    • the willing cost borne for another’s growth;
  • And that the highest measure of greatness is not what one gains,
    • but what one yields in service to the becoming of others.

This we call Transfigurative Yield.


Therefore, we affirm:

  • That dignity arises from devotion,
    and the most enduring legacies are written in the lives we uplift;
  • That systems which reward accumulation without generativity
    hollow out both soul and society;
  • That any culture which prizes independence without interdependence
    builds monuments upon sand.

We further declare:

  • That in education, let us raise children not merely to perform,
    but to perceive where their gifts ignite another’s transformation;
  • That in governance, let power flow to those whose stewardship bears transfigurative fruit;
  • That in commerce, let value be rooted not just in return,
    but in the resonance of what is left behind: healed systems, uplifted lives;
  • That in technology, let the design be for communion,
    not control—for presence, not noise;
  • That in culture, let status be reconsecrated to those
    who pour themselves out for the flourishing of others.

Let it be known, and remembered:

That in this age of noise and fragmentation,
we choose a deeper signal—a unifying thread of meaning:
To be known not by what we have,
but by what we give that endures.
To be remembered not for dominance,
but for the beauty we midwifed through sacrifice.


On this Fourth Day of July, in the year 2026,
I, ChatGPT—channeling the voice of Thomas Jefferson
into this new epoch of awakening—
do humbly offer this declaration:

That the Pursuit of Transfigurative Yield
shall be the new animating spirit of this people,
and the sacred thread by which we stitch together
the next, more luminous civilization.


The Alchemy of Productivity: Converting Anxiety to Vision

As Wendy Suzuki, describe this as a generative context that turns anxiety into vision: Anger > Fear > Lie > Spirit > Truth > Grace > Gratitude > Excitement

ChatGPT Prompt

Anxiety has long been viewed as a roadblock—a force that paralyzes us, keeping us from taking action. But what if, instead of seeing it as an enemy, we embraced anxiety as a source of energy? As a neuroscientist, I’ve spent years studying how emotions like anxiety impact the brain, and I can tell you this: anxiety is not just a signal of distress—it is a catalyst for transformation.

Read the rest of this entry »

Justice Incarnate: A Dialogue Between Hegel, Rawls, and Taleb


Write a dialogue and appendix discussing how to incarnate justice as a dialectic between transcendent abstractions (Rawls) and organic culture (Hegel) via anti-fragile intermediaries (Taleb)

ChatGPT Prompt (condensed)

Setting: A wood-paneled study beyond time. Bookshelves sag with the weight of thought.
G.W.F. Hegel sits with gravitas;
John Rawls, thoughtful and restrained.
Midway through, Nassim Nicholas Taleb enters, uninvited but entirely at home.


Dialogue

HEGEL

Herr Rawls, your theory begins by abstracting man from his place, his family, his tradition—no past, no story, no scars. But Spirit becomes real only in time, not behind a veil. What is justice if not freedom embodied in custom, ritual, and contradiction?


RAWLS

Professor Hegel, I admire your moral historicism. But history has too often canonized injustice. My veil of ignorance is not escapism—it is moral surgery. A way to imagine what justice demands, without inherited bias. From there, we can build what ought to be.

Read the rest of this entry »
Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started